GLDN offers the cream of the crop when it comes to personalized jewelry for a few reasons. For starters, most of its offerings are under the $200 mark, with this insanely cute 14K gold initial locket necklace coming in at just $98 ($93 if sterling silver is more your thing). With this necklace, you can choose between three chain options and you can engrave it with a single letter or leave it blank. The brand also offers a variety of unique, customizable jewelry options from rings and necklaces to bracelets, making it the perfect place to shop for a gift. 

Best Known For: Customization

Shipping & Return Policy: If you need a gift by Valentine’s Day, GLDN is offering rush shipping on certain items. If you’d like to return an item, you can send it back for a refund (minus an $8 shipping and handling fee) within 30 days of your delivery date. Your return will be processed one to two weeks after they receive your return.

Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. GLDN is  a STYLECASTER sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.

Gorjana is your one-stop-shop for fine jewelry purchases. While many of its high quality options tip well over the $200 mark, this little 18K gold-plated gem is only $55 and comes with a custom initial of your choice.

Best Known For: Fine jewelry 

Shipping & Return Policy: Gorjana offers free standard shipping on all domestic orders in the U.S. and Puerto Rico. Returns are accepted on all unworn items within 30 days of purchase.

This genuine diamond letter charm is all luxury without the insane price tag. While it doesn’t come with a chain, that makes it even easier to pair with different types of jewelry. And just in time for Valentine’s Day, Mejuri’s gift guide section features an array of other jewelry options with gems that suit a variety of budgets.

Best Known For: Jewelry with gems

Shipping & Return Policy: Mejuri offers free 30-day returns for customers in the U.S., Canada, the U.K, Australia, and Germany starting from the day the shipment is delivered or picked up in-store.

This Abbot Lyon bracelet has so many different charm options that it’s almost overwhelming. There are so many different routes you can go creatively and the bracelet is even sweat-, water-, and heat-resistant. 

Best Known For: Charms

Shipping & Return Policy: Abbott Lyon offers free standard shipping on all U.S. orders. You can return or exchange an item within 100 days of the delivery date.

While there are a ton of great customized jewelry options on this list, Oak and Luna offers some of the best. With this gold-plated initial necklace, you can anywhere from one to eight different letters. There’s also the option to add a diamond or two and you can opt for a silver, gold, or rose gold chain—the options are endless.

Best Known For: Customization

Shipping & Return Policy: Oak and Luna offers free shipping on all orders within the U.S. Personalized jewelry can only be returned for an exchange or store credit within 60 days of purchase. 

For the best custom engraving under $200, look no further than Kendra Scott’s Elaina 18K Gold Bracelet (or get it in sterling silver). This design is classic, minimalist, and the engraving on this one is complementary.  

Best Known For: Personalized jewelry, modern pieces

Shipping & Return Policy: Kendra Scott offers free shipping on orders over $85. 

If you like giving a subtle nod to your personal astrology, Brook & York offers this customizable three-birthstone charm necklace. With a paperclip-style chain, it’s available in 14K gold-plated material and sterling silver. The brand also has a few other birthstone necklace options that allow you to add an additional initial charm or multiple—you can truly make it your own.

Best Known For: Add ons and extras

Shipping & Return Policy: Brook & York offers free economy shipping on all U.S. orders. Economy shipping takes five to seven days to be delivered after your order is processed. If you’d like to return an item, they accept returns within 60 days of purchase. Personalized items are non-returnable, including items that have been engraved.

BaubleBar has so many good customizable jewelry options that it’s hard to choose a top pick, but this custom initial keychain is my personal favorite. You can choose between one, two, and three letters for personalization and while it’s technically labeled as a kid’s keychain, the color scheme is cute (and subtle) enough for adults, too. I’ve gotten so many compliments on it and it’s only $20—a total steal. 

Best Known For: Trendy designs

Shipping & Return Policy: This item is final sale and not eligible for returns. It cannot be canceled or altered once submitted.

One thing I’ve never thought to add to my personalized jewelry is my birth flower. This Etsy seller makes it easy for you. You can select your birth month from the drop down customization menu and you’ll receive an image of a bouquet of yours. You can even customize the chain length and number of flowers on the charm. It’s totally unique and the perfect option for a Mother’s Day gift.

Best Known For: Unique finds and local artists

Shipping & Return Policy: This shop offers free shipping but doesn’t typically accept returns or exchanges. You can, however, contact the seller if there is an issue with your order.

This simple, budget-friendly initial necklace
is perfect for an impulse “treat yourself” moment. It’s just $12 on Amazon, boasts hundreds of five-star reviews, and is composed of 14K gold-plated brass material. It’s perfect for everyday wear and you can adjust the length of the chain to be worn as a standard necklace or choker.

Best Known For: Value

Shipping & Return Policy: This item offers Prime shipping. Amazon allows customers to return most items within 30 days of delivery for a refund or replacement.